Page 43 - RFU Annual Report 2018
P. 43

4
                                                                             CORPORATE GOVERNANCE



                                                                                                               1










              Internal audit                  External auditors              Evaluation of the Audit Committee
              Internal audit is an independent and   Following the recommendation of the   The Committee carried out an
              objective assurance function which   Committee, the Directors proposed the   assessment of its own performance
              aims to assess and improve the RFU’s   re-appointment of Mazars as the Group’s   during the year.  While overall the
              overall control framework.  Internal   external auditors for 2018.  Members   members concluded that the Committee
              audit at the RFU is undertaken by   approved the appointment of Mazars at   is performing effectively,  they requested
              RSM, an independent accountancy   the AGM on the 8th June 2018.   that more information be provided
              firm.  The Audit Committee defines the                         by management on key topics, and
              responsibility and scope of the internal   Both the RFU and Mazars have   that meetings be extended to allow
              audit function and approves its annual   safeguards in place to avoid the   further time for discussion of key
              plan.                           possibility that the external auditor’s   topics. It was agreed that the number
                                              objectivity and independence could be   of Audit Committee meetings should
              During the year, the Committee   compromised, such as audit partner   be increased to four per annum going
              evaluated the performance of the   rotation and the restriction of non-audit   forward.
              internal auditors and was satisfied with   services that the external auditors can
              their effectiveness.            perform.  The Committee reviewed the   Consolidated financial statements
                                              report from Mazars on the actions they   The Committee recommended to the
              Audit of the Annual Financial   take to comply with the professional   Board of Directors, and the Board has
              Statements                      and regulatory requirements and   approved, that the audited consolidated
              The external auditors, Mazars, reported   best practice designed to ensure their   financial statements be included in the
              in depth to the Committee on the   independence from the RFU.  The   Annual Report for the year ended 30
              scope and outcome of the annual   Committee was satisfied with Mazars’   June 2018.
              audit.  This reporting included their   independence.
              significant findings, internal control
              recommendations and summary of   During the year, Mazars did not carry
              misstatements.                  out any work for the RFU, apart from the
                                              external audit.
              The Committee held independent
              meetings with the external auditors   Mazars have been external auditors
              during the year and reviewed and   for the RFU since 2006, with a partner
              agreed their audit plan.  The Committee   rotation in 2012.    The last tender for the
              discussed the views and conclusions   audit of the annual accounts was carried
              of Mazars regarding management’s   out in 2014.
              treatment of significant transactions
              and areas of judgement during the year
              and Mazars confirmed that they were
              satisfied that these had been treated
              appropriately in the financial statements.
              In particular, the Committee focussed on
              areas of potential disagreement between
              management and the external auditors
              and how these had been resolved.

























                                                                                                            Annual
                                                                                                            Report
                                                                                                            2018
   38   39   40   41   42   43   44   45   46   47   48